WE WELCOME THOSE WITH A GENUINE INTEREST IN BING CROSBY. YOU WILL BE ASKED THREE QUESTIONS WHEN YOU REGISTER. DEPENDING ON YOUR ANSWERS, WE WILL EITHER APPROVE OR NOT APPROVE YOUR MEMBERSHIP. This requirement arises from misuse of the forum by a few.
KEEP AN EYE ON:-
Jon Oye keeps adding images to his site Contemplations on Classic Movies and Music
David Lobosco has continual additions to his site The Bing Crosby News Archive
Tony Mead adds photos and other interesting material Bing's Photos
NOTE: If you are having trouble logging in, please contact David Lobosco at davidlobosco@yahoo.com.
Offline
A copy of Bing's first recording has appeared on e-bay!
Unfortunately, judging from the accompanying pictures, it doesn't seem to be in great condition, but this is the first time I've seen one crop up on e-bay... I've been looking for a copy for years, but given the condition I'll think I'll keep looking..!
Offline

That price is a little high. I paid $50 for my copy (after searching forever). It is in VG condition.
I would pass too at that starting price.
Offline
John Bassett has just emailed me as follows.
"I wonder if any members were aware of the fact that an original 78 of “I’ve Got The Girl” was up for auction on Ebay in mid-August. To my knowledge, this is the third time in two years that Bing’s historic “first” has appeared on the global selling site by way of two American issues and one UK issue. Collectors cannot bemoan that these rare items never see the light of day! 824-D sold a couple of days ago for £70.59 on eBay.co.uk. Sorry to say I wasn’t lucky in this instance!"
Offline
Jeremy,
I clicked on the site you mention but there is an - oomphs, the page is missing message.
Ron
Offline
I"VE GOT THE GIRL ,on original 78rpm release is still a fine collectable find. As played however ,it revealed a botched job. Chipmunk voices? The very fine re-mastered version ,that I first got to hear myself (in 1977) , is an excellent piece of 1926 jazz band music. The peppy vocals (from Bing & Al) ,as re-mastered ,also add much joy to it!
Offline
Colin, you may well have read Richard Baker's article on 78rpm speeds in issue 187 of 'Bing', to which yours truly makes a small contribution. 'Bing' 188 contains a follow-up article by Mark Scrimger which to my mind - having been granted a sneak preview - gives a definitive last word on the subject. (Despite the fact that that last word leaves at least one of my own conclusions smouldering in the embers..!)
Offline
The article will be in BING189 due out next month.
Offline
Gary Giddins ,in his POCKET FULL OF DREAMS, notes the problem with IV'E GOT THE GIRL (pg. 145-147. For me, a long time before Giddons, it was my good friend, Richard Wagner. As a (Chicago, ILL) 78RPM record collector, he found ways to play old 10 inch records using many speeds .He figured it out. It would be a good guess that Richard himself did the re-mastering before anyone else had thought of it? This very good man has been gone for a long time now, so he can't be asked. In any case, this is the kind of commercial recording that remains a huge WHAT IF.....
Offline
Apologies for straying away from the playing speed and format of 78rpm with this one but is there a specific remastered version of this recording anyone could recommend of those subsequently made available on CD?
Offline
Price very steep for a 78 considering they can break very easily if it's not well packaged that's why it's better to obtain a CD that has the song on it. it'a on "The Chronogical Bing Crosby vol ! CD as well as a Naxos CD "Classic Crosby" as well as the 4 CD set on Proper "It's Easy To Remember"
Last edited by STEPO (11/8/2025 1:22 pm)
Offline
STEPO wrote:
Price very steep for a 78 considering they can break very easily if it's not well packaged that's why it's better to obtain a CD that has the song on it. it'a on "The Chronogical Bing Crosby vol ! CD as well as a Naxos CD "Classic Crosby" as well as the 4 CD set on Proper "It's Easy To Remember"
Thanks, Stepo.
I've recently (and finally) managed to obtain a fine sounding transfer of this record (to my tin ears, anyway) on the Naxos CD "The Earliest Bing Crosby, Vol.1, Rhythm King, Original Recordings 1926-1930". Apologies for not knowing how to post an illustration on here of the cover.
It's the very first time I've heard the full recording and it was enjoyed immensely. I had previously only heard the few snatched seconds featured on Barry Norman's superb 1985 BBC television "Hollywood Greats" portrait of Bing.
Although of course there's no clue via Bing and Al's spirited vocal refrain on that first recording as to what the next fifty-one years would bring, it's such an evocatively charming, foot tapping piece of near century recorded history which made me tingle all over. And all just costing me under three English pounds - and I'm now wondering why on earth after forty-five years of curiosity didn't I even think to just sneak a curious listen online via YouTube or my "Alexa" Amazon Music funded pod speaker?
I'll leave that one to the jury.
Offline
You're welcome Ian always glad to help out , as for the songs obscurity it's maybe because Don Clark was an obscure and is long forgotten unlike Paul Whiteman as well as the fact that Bing and Al's (Al Rinker that is) vocals are only on a small portion of the recording it's quite possible that Bing himself might not have cared for the song because he didn't include the song on the "Bing A Musical Autobiography" set in 1954.
Last edited by STEPO (12/10/2025 8:38 pm)
Offline
Bing and Al made this recording discreetly. They had just signed with Whiteman and they should have rejected the Don Clark offer. Rinker remembers that they were very curious about how will they be on records and accepeted. The song remained totally unknown and in 1951 when Ed Mello and Tom McBride created teh first Crosby discography they failed to include it. Bing himslef corrected them and mention that his first record was I 've Got the Girl.
Offline
I am most grateful, Stepo and Pantelis.
I admit, I would never have known Don Clark's name without this first record of Bing's.
I've done a little searching online and have come up with virtually nothing extra on him.
Nice to know he was an ex employee of the still remembered Paul Whiteman.
Yes, I must confess, until way after the advent of the compact disc, I'd never seen Bing's first recording featured on any long playing vinyl compilations. I'm not at all inferring that they weren't available but during my teenage years and twenties (in the 1980's and '90's), record shops in the UK in my home city of Nottingham, had plenty of new and second hand Crosby compilations and yet I never saw it featured on any.
Towards the end of the 'eighties, I did enquire at a specialist shop (who despite my pestering, eventually went on to employ me) and was told where it would more than likely feature - but still without managing to obtain a copy.
I indeed purchased a copy of Bing's "Musical Autobiography" box set (from "Music Inn", the same specialist shop) and due to already having been accustomed for years of "I've Got The Girl" always being absent, it never even occurred to me that it may have been present on there. But now you come to mention it, I wonder if it could also have been missing on the autobiography box set due to rights reasons - or Bing not wishing to look any further back before becoming a solo name?
Pantelis, I wonder with what you have written, if the recording's obscurity continued into the next decade or two - hence my not being able to see it on anything of those vinyl compiations?
Last edited by Ian Kerstein (13/10/2025 6:39 am)