08/4/2025 3:28 pm  #1


A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

I recently rewatched Bing's movie Billboard Girl, a 1932 short movie that he did with Mack Sennet and one of the songs featured in it, "For You," stood out to me. I was surprised to discover that Bing never made a commercial recording of this song. It's such a lovely piece and seemed like it had the potential to become a hit. Interestingly, Bing performed it three times on his radio show in 1931. However, it's no surprise the song was eventually forgotten—it wasn't available in record shops, and it appears that no one else recorded it during that year. Also, the Hollywood of Bing collection focuses on songs from after 1934, leaving this overlooked.

 It's rather curious, considering that Bing was recording many songs during that period and often turned his movie songs into records. The song also served as a theme in the picture's overture. 

 "For You" was written in 1930 by Joe Burke and Al Dubin. The film was shot in 1931 and released in 1932. Later, the song was covered by notable artists such as Perry Como, Dean Martin, Rosemary Clooney, and Patti Page. It even became a hit when Ricky Nelson recorded it in 1964. Despite this, Bing never included "For You" in his later radio shows or made a record of it.

 In 1933, Brunswick Records (while Bing was working there) released a recording of "For You" performed by a dance band. In 1937, Decca Records (which had Bing under contract at the time) released another version featuring Kenny Sargent as the vocalist. 

It is a very nice song and it could have becomce a very nice record with Bing and some nice arrangment.

This is the link to the movie version of the song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6Ph5u0IXQs

  

Last edited by Pantelis Kavouras (08/4/2025 3:28 pm)

 

08/4/2025 10:50 pm  #2


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

I agree Pantelis! Love that song. I love Bing the Crooner. So melting. Nobody sang those Crooner songs like Bing. "For You" with the right arrangements would have been even better. Too bad some songs were not given more attention but there were so many good songs Bing released back then that some were just passed over.

 

09/4/2025 7:05 pm  #3


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

Yes that's right but it is strange that a movie song (the main song of the short picture) would be overlooked like that, and also is strange that Bing never revived it, if only for radio use, even when his song became hit for others.

     Thread Starter
 

09/4/2025 8:44 pm  #4


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

Maybe Bing did not like the song? Good questions.

 

10/4/2025 11:08 am  #5


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

It could be the case, but it is strange, he sung so so many songs in his radio shows, he wasn't very picky, he sung almost everything but who knows, perhaps that's the reason. I like the song a lot, but it could have became a hit with the suitable arrangments in 1930s or even in 1960s as the song became hit material for so many artists for so long.

     Thread Starter
 

10/4/2025 5:07 pm  #6


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

I remember reading he was offered "Unchanged Melody" and turned it down. Years later after it was a hit for the Righteous Brothers, he recorded it.

 

12/4/2025 11:14 am  #7


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

I agree' it's a good song, sung so well by Bing.

 

12/4/2025 9:27 pm  #8


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

Blonde56 wrote:

I remember reading he was offered "Unchanged Melody" and turned it down. Years later after it was a hit for the Righteous Brothers, he recorded it.

Warner Brothers produced a prison movie called Unchained. Alex North was hired by WB to write a title song, he used an unpublished tune he had written in the 1930s and worked with the lyricist Hy Jaret for the final song.
The song was completed and included in the movie, the longing for love is one of the centrals themes of the picture. At the same time Kathryn Grant was released from her Paramount contract and was looking for a job, she tested for a part in the picture and got it. Kathryn Grant and Barbara Hale played the leading parts, with Kathryn portraying Sally Haskins, the significant other of a prisoner.

Warner Brothers producers were pleased with thesweet innocence in her performance on a charged scene in the prison yard, and thougt that her role had dramatic possibilities, after completing her job in WB she was offered a contract with Columbia Pictures and within a year (after two bit parts) she was one of the most promising Columbia stars, starring in four pictures per year and receiving top-billing in several short movies.
 
The song serves as an emotional hymn dedicated to the missed loved ones of the prisoners, a sentiment portrayed through the characters played by Kathryn Grant, Barbara Hale, and Peggy Knudsen.
 
When Unchained, premiered in January of 1955 Kathryn was already romantically involved with Bing, who asked her just few weeks after the premier, to accompany him to the Oscars, It's likely that Bing discovered the song due to Kathryn’s role in the film he. As it was a WB project is unlikely, they considered a Paramount star like Bing to introduce the song in the picture and the choice of the unknown vocalist Todd Duncan suggests they didn’t expected much of it. In the months after the picture’s release the song became quite popular and performed well on the charts.

Bing recorded Unchained Melody on June 9, 1955 with Buddy Cole and his trio and he helped popularize it by broadcasting it 6 more times in his weekly radio show in 1955 alone. This recording was one of the earliest made, years before the Righteous Borthers version.

He even included the song on the episode that aired on November 25 the birthday of Kathryn. A nod to Kathryn's role in the picture.
 

Last edited by Pantelis Kavouras (12/4/2025 9:28 pm)

     Thread Starter
 

12/4/2025 9:34 pm  #9


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

HLC Properties and Primary Wave included the song on the 2023 digital album "A Valentine From Bing"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-1WMHwpYWk
 

     Thread Starter
 

13/4/2025 12:58 am  #10


Re: A Forgotten Song from Billboard Girl: "For You"

Wow! Thanks Panelists for all that info! I guess the book I got my info from was totally wrong.

 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum

Spread the word about CROSBY FAN WORLD http://crosbyfanworld.boardhost.com